Marketing

How to Perform a Facebook Ads Audit to Maximize the Effectiveness of Your Campaign

Ready to leverage your Facebook ads strategy? Learn the most effective Facebook Ads auditing approaches from more than 20 marketing professionals.

Melissa King Melissa King on February 2, 2021 (last modified on February 4, 2021) • 14 minute read


Did you know that Facebook’s advertising audience consists of 2.14 billion users? With so many people consuming Facebook Ads, you want to make sure that every ad campaign you run makes an impact. And that’s where a Facebook ads audit comes in.

We asked more than 20 marketing experts and ad pros to share their tactics for auditing Facebook Ads. Before diving into the tactics, let’s learn more about Facebook Ads and how to perform audits that drive meaningful change.

What is a Facebook Ads Audit?

A Facebook Ads audit is an analysis of a Facebook Ads account’s best practices and effectiveness. Someone who performs an audit aims to look for strengths and areas of improvement to inform their strategy moving forward.

Editor’s note: While you plan out your Facebook Ads audit, try loading up the Facebook Ads Campaign Performance Dashboard Template in Databox. This dashboard offers a top-down view of your campaign’s performance that can help you guide your audit.

Facebook Ads Campaign Performance Dashboard Template

How Do I Perform a Facebook Ads Audit?

There’s no one way to perform a Facebook Ads audit. The auditing process depends on the auditor’s priorities and preferences. Most audits cover aspects of the account’s audience targeting, ad creative, campaign structure, account overview, and landing pages.

Since audits vary based on the person who performs them, we consulted digital advertising experts about their preferred methods. We first asked them what area of auditing they considered the most important:

most important facebook ads audit areas

As you can see in the above graph, most respondents — about 25% — think that audience targeting and optimization come first. In descending order, the next most important areas were the ad creative, campaign structure, account overview, and landing pages. None of the answers dipped below 10%, demonstrating that each of these areas is pretty important to a significant number of marketers.

How can you insightfully audit each area of Facebook Ad management? Let’s learn from the pros.

Audience targeting and optimization

The quarter of our survey participants who put audience targeting at the top of their priority lists had plenty of insights to share about this facet of Facebook Ads.

If you have to prioritize one element of Facebook Ads during an audit, Bryan Philips from In Motion Marketing thinks you should focus on audience targeting and optimization. “A lot of businesses want to focus on the creative side of things, and that’s important,” Philips acknowledges.

“But when you’re thinking about overall value, targeting your ads properly necessitates that you’ll find more fans. If I had to choose, I would rather get my message to my audience with a not so stellar packaging than not get it to them at all,” they explain.

Related: Facebook Ad Impressions: Definitions, Benchmarks, and Ways to Improve

“The ad itself might be effective, but if it’s not reaching the right people, that effort produces a minimal return on investment,” Kintell’s Mark Hayes adds. Hayes recommends looking at audience targeting as a preliminary step. “Afterwards, the structure of the campaign, the copy used, and the overview of the account itself can be taken into account,” they conclude.

Marketer Jackie Kossoff recommends knowing Facebook parameters inside and out when defining your audience. “Oftentimes, I find that people choose targeting parameters without ascertaining how Facebook defines that specific parameter. You may be unknowingly targeting a completely different audience group than you intended,” Kossoff says.

Facebook also has a built-in feature to help you determine if your ads reach enough people in your audience. According to Tiffany Lewis of More Meaningful Marketing, “Facebook has a meter to show you the audience range your ad has the potential to reach. Make sure the needle is past the halfway mark on the meter. This will give you a great way to benchmark greater results.”

Ad creative

Facebook Ads experts like Pedro Campos from Advertongue consider ad creative — a Facebook Ad’s headline, body copy, and image — the most important aspect to audit. Their logic: “Campaigns with strong creative will always drive better ROI. Therefore, creating ads worth sharing should be your number priority on Facebook.”

When looking at ad creative, Campos makes congruency top priority, saying, “Congruency translated is consistency. Remember that people follow and trust consistent messages and brands. What we´re talking about here is consistency in your messaging, landing pages, branding, and imagery.”

They continue, “You can’t tell one story in the ad and take people to a landing page with a different story. When this happens, the ad has lost the scent, in other words, psychologically it doesn’t make sense, people will get confused when they hit the landing page and will most likely not take any action.”

James Smith from Profit Guru uses A/B testing to evaluate ad creative and other elements of Facebook Ads. “If you want to be driving more clicks to your website, compare your ads and run the one that drives the most clicks for the least amount of money,” Smith says. They instruct you to modify “images, headlines, body copy, placement, and so on and see which changes bring you the best results.”

Zutrix’s Kristel Staci agrees, stating, “Which text and image ad copy has performed best over time is always important. By analyzing what has worked well in the past, we can create new variations of the same ad copy and landing pages, then expand out into different audience targeting.”

Campaign structure

Your Facebook Ads campaign’s structure also influences how many people will see and interact with them. It takes a comprehensive understanding of your objectives and Facebook’s algorithm to develop a successful campaign.

“There’s a reason why campaign objectives are the first thing [Facebook asks] when you are creating a new campaign because this is what [Facebook] will use to optimize your campaign,” explains John Hewitt from Netbooks Review. “Facebook’s machine learning plays a big role in determining how and when your ad is served, and building your campaigns around the campaign objective allows you to work in tandem with their algorithm.”

According to JC Social Media’s David Glenwright, you should also keep the customer journey in mind when building a campaign structure. Glenwright states, “The most important thing that I look for during an audit is being able to see a clear and logical user journey. If the brand’s product/service is complex or expensive, there need to be campaigns dedicated to nurturing relationships rather than trying to drive sales.”

Jordania Nelson of Divining Point urges you to ask yourself these questions when organizing your campaigns:

“Assessing the campaign names can tell you how the account is organized: Are they named after the audience? This mistake tells you the objective isn’t being prioritized.

Are the campaigns catered towards accurate and distinctive audiences?

Are ad sets being used within multiple campaigns? This causes your own ads to compete with each other, resulting in delivery disruptions.

Are A/B tests being utilized? Ads should use this feature to ensure organized testing for future optimizations.”

Account overview

Your Facebook Ads account overview may seem minor in comparison to other aspects of your Facebook advertising, but it determines plenty of your campaigns’ underlying organization.

Here’s how Cristina Maria from Commusoft puts it: “It might seem pedantic, but a messy overview with mislabelled or vague campaign names can easily lead to losing track of things, especially if you run ads regularly or you want to continuously optimize. If you’re not in control of observing and tracking, you’re definitely not in control of the results.”

To keep their account view organized, the Commusoft team titles each campaign with its main objective, such as “increase qualified traffic to website.” Maria asserts that “the goal should dictate your campaign, not the existence of an audience.”

Editor’s note: Don’t neglect your Facebook Pages account while you’re evaluating your Ads account. The Facebook Pages & Facebook Ads: Engagement Summary dashboard in Databox collects performance data from both Facebook platforms to help you understand the connection between your Ads and Page.

Facebook Pages & Facebook Ads: Engagement Summary dashboard

Landing pages

As you tinker with your Facebook Ads on Facebook’s end, remember to keep your landing pages in good shape as well.

“From our experience, no matter how crafty, controversial or elegant an ad is in both its visual and copywriting elements, if the final product landing page looks like a hot mess, then your conversion rate is going to plummet,” Networq’s Zak N. Wilkins tells us.

Brice Gump from Major Impact Media reminds you to optimize your landing page’s loading speed, explaining, “Everyone looks at the campaign structure, targeting and ads which is important. But don’t forget to audit your landing pages to make sure they are loading fast enough for users to experience them. Always shoot for under 2 seconds.”

At LIFTOFF Digital, Nathaniel Rodriguez keeps an eye out for proper conversion tracking when auditing a landing page. “Without conversion tracking installed on your website, you are shooting in the dark and don’t know what’s working or not working. Especially if you’re an e-commerce store, without conversion tracking you don’t know what ads are driving customers and which aren’t,” says Rodriguez.

11 More Areas to Consider Auditing

Outside of the five critical areas we examined in our survey, the professionals who provided insights mentioned 11 other metrics and features to track. Depending on the metric, your setup, and your personal preferences, you can evaluate these elements in Facebook Ads Manager or create custom metrics in Databox.

  1. Cost-per-install
  2. Outlier metrics
  3. Costs versus conversion
  4. Cost-per-result
  5. Cost-per-click
  6. Campaign goal
  7. Facebook Ad Placement
  8. Facebook Ads Report
  9. Competitive landscape
  10. Results attribution
  11. Relevance score

1. Cost-per-install

As Josh Wood from Bloc demonstrates, your audit priorities should depend on your industry’s measures of success. “I’m in the app world, so during a Facebook Ads audit, I’m simply looking for the lowest CPI (cost-per-install) possible,” Wood tells us.

They elaborate, “I keep a close eye on this marker to see if it’s increasing over time. If it is, then it probably means the frequency is too high.”

2. Outlier metrics

The trends in your ad metrics and numbers that go against those trends can also inform your audit, according to Twibi’s Brenton Thomas. During an audit, Thomas looks for “click-through rates, cost-per-conversion and cost-per-landing-page views that are abnormally high or low.” They explain, “Based on the analytics, I then know where the largest opportunities exist to optimize within the account.”

3. Costs versus conversion

At CanIRank, Matt Bentley compares the average number of times someone sees an ad to conversion rates to figure out costs versus conversion. Bently says, “The most important metric we look for when conducting a Facebook Ads audit is cost versus conversion. If the overall number of conversions drops after a long period of stability, it’s time to take a closer look at the reach and frequency of your campaign.”

According to Bentley, one rule of thumb helps with optimizing costs versus conversion.”Most people are unlikely to engage with your ad if they’ve already seen it 10 times. Our rule of thumb? If an ad is approaching a frequency of 4, it’s time to consider new ad creative. Pro tip: Set a frequency cap,” they advise.

4. Cost-per-result

Cody Murphy at Visual Oak creates a “target cost-per-result when starting a campaign, which is calculated by dividing the number of results by the amount spent on the campaign.” The result you measure will depend on your KPIs, such as acquisition or conversion. “If we’re exceeding the target cost-per-result, it’s time to take a look at the creative, landing page and our targeted audience because something needs further optimization.”

Related: 24 Effective Strategies to Reduce Facebook Ads CPA

5. Cost-per-click

The most important thing that Eyanki Media’s Ruchika Gupta looks for while running affiliate product ads on Facebook is cost-per-click (CPC), which they compare to the CPC for their other ad sets.

“Any tremendous rise in CPC gives a clear indication that you need to re-optimize your campaign to improve your ad’s relevancy score,” Gupta establishes. “Sometimes [you need] simple tweaks in ad creatives, target audience, or improving ad’s engagement work. Generally, improving the ad’s CTR (click-through rate) helps decrease the ad’s CPC,” they explain.

Gupta has one caveat: “But before doing anything, check your campaign’s ROI; if it [has] good ROI, it’s better to let it run for a while and check back if any action is needed.”

6. Campaign goal

When performing a Facebook Ads audit, sometimes it’s necessary to return to your campaign’s foundation — its goal. According to RJ Huebert at HBT Digital Consulting, “One important thing I look at during a Facebook audit is the campaign goal – what does the business hope to accomplish? When you select your campaign goal, it’s so important to understand if you want awareness, consideration, or conversions.”

The Facebook Business Help Center defines each of these goal categories. Awareness campaigns generate interest, consideration campaigns make people think about your product or service and conversion campaigns aim to convert customers.

7. Facebook Ad Placement

Courtney Quigley of Rize Reviews recommends visiting the Facebook Ad Placement function under Ads Settings, explaining that “this audit will translate results you generate from the ads to understand better what works and what doesn’t.”

The Ad Placements options also let you control your ad location by platform. You can learn more about controlling your ad placements in the Facebook Business Help Center’s guide.

8. Facebook Ads Reporting

Facebook Ads has another auditing tool available at your fingertips — Ads Reporting. Ads reporting helps you to optimize your Facebook marketing campaigns further by evaluating the performance of an ad, ad set, or campaign.

If you want to try Ads Reporting for yourself, you can learn how to use it from the Business Help Center’s official guide.

9. Competitive landscape

Like with any marketing or advertising channel, Facebook Ad managers should understand their competitive landscape before starting any other step. “Too many marketers and businesses start running Facebook Ads without actually analyzing what their competitors do. This is a huge mistake,” Jonathan Aufray from Growth Hackers affirms.

Aufray explains, “You want to check what kinds of ads your competitors are running, what kinds of visuals, copies, and CTAs they’re using. Why?”

The answer: “You don’t want to start from scratch. You want to learn from your competition, be inspired by them, and create better, more engaging, and compelling ads than them.”

10. Results attribution

While serving clients at Lake One, Andrew Schulz has noticed that clients miss out on one of Facebook Ad Manager’s customizable features. Did you know that you can customize attribution windows for your Facebook Ads?

Let’s hear it from Schulz: “Too often, our clients have been previously trained to rely only on Facebook’s default attribution window to measure results. We recommend taking a look at the Facebook attribution window and adjusting to align with business goals and channel performance.”

11. Relevance score

Another powerful metric in Facebook Ads Manager is the relevance score. Kohezion’s Thierry Tremblay defines the relevance score as “a 1-10 score that Facebook gives ads based on interactions from the audience.”

The Kohezion team owes their ad performance to the insights they get from relevance scores. “Whenever we were scoring low with dozens of adverts, it was a sign that our targeting was off. It helped us better generate new leads and understand how [users] view our ads. We considered the optimal audience’s ideal age, location, gender, behaviors, and interests,” Tremblay says.

Ashley Glenn from Next PR points out that the relevance score “is broken down into three separate categories — quality score, engagement rate ranking and conversion rate ranking. In each category, you’re given a score that ranges from below average to above average using feedback on your ads and the post-click experience. The scores are measured against other ads that competed for the same audience.”

Glenn continues, “The best part about this metric is that it’s calculated for each individual ad, so you can see exactly which ads in your campaign are striking the best response with your audience. While these scores are only estimates, you can determine whether or not your ads are reaching a highly-engaged, relevant audience that is likely to be interested in the product or service you’re promoting.”

About the author
Melissa King
Melissa King Melissa King is a freelance writer who helps B2B SaaS companies spread the word about their products through engaging content. Outside of the content marketing world, she writes about video games. Check out her work at melissakingfreelance.com.

Comments are closed.

You may also like...
Read more

Which Sources Drive The Highest Conversion Rates?

Which one of your marketing investments is driving the most conversions? Check out this Data Snack and increase your conversion rates by source.

Data Snacks   |  Jul 30

Read more

When Should You Use Google Ads Smart Bidding? Advice from 20+ PPC Experts

Should you opt for manual or automated Google Ads bidding? Nearly 30 PPC experts share their top tips on when to use smart bidding.

Marketing   |  Jul 29

Read more

9 Customer Segmentation Tips to Personalize Ecommerce Marketing and Drive More Sales

Segmenting your customer base can enhance your ecommerce marketing efforts as it allows a more personal approach. Find out how it can drive more sales for your business.

Marketing   |  Jul 26