How This Veteran Agency Leader Leverages Data to Win Bigger Accounts

John McTigue sets Kuno Creative apart from other agencies by digging deeper into his prospect’s data.

Kevin Kononenko on May 23, 2017 (last modified on October 29, 2022) • 6 minute read

At the end of 2016, Kuno Creative wanted to uncover the factors that separated profitable clients from unprofitable ones.

John McTigue and Chris Knipper, the leaders of Kuno, were ready to double down on their profitable clients and have the confidence to turn away engagements that were unlikely to end in the black. So, they did an internal audit to discover which factors defined a better client. Specifically, they looked at:

  1. Client Traffic
  2. Sales Conversion Rates
  3. Number of Contacts in Marketing Database
  4. Industry
  5. Size of client

Then, they correlated it to:

  1. Revenue
  2. Upsell Potential
  3. Lifetime Value

They quickly found they had consistent, excellent engagements and higher margins with one narrow market segment comprised of only about 20 companies. These companies had 2 major factors in common:

  1. In the medical device or industrial manufacturing industry
  2. Over $50 million in annual revenue

Even though they had plenty of contacts in this industry from 17 years in business, John realized they would need to try a different approach to sales and marketing if they wanted to close more of their ideal customers. Other digital agencies were also eager for this business and would likely try to undercut them on price.

“We did not want to start the relationship by giving standard recommendations like, ‘you should implement more¬†lead forms’ or other tips usually offered in a¬†consultation from other HubSpot partners,” said John.

Video Summary

They Used Data to Provide More Value Up-Front

John wanted to show these prospects that Kuno was uniquely qualified to solve their problems. So, he started using tactics from account-based marketing and sales. A target account-based approach focuses on clients with greater upfront and lifetime value. This allowed him to justify the increased time spent on each prospect.

John wanted to show that nobody could match the value provided by Kuno.

“In the past, some clients would treat us like a cleaning service. They just made¬†sure that we completed¬†the work that we agreed upon. In our ideal engagements, we successfully¬†shifted these¬†conversations to actual performance.”

John had already worked with a holding company that owned many of his top prospect accounts. From the past work, he knew that many brands only had one digital strategy manager and a very small team. They were significantly understaffed for the challenges associated with executing a full digital marketing strategy.

To get face-time with key leaders from his target accounts, Kuno was invited to an internal marketing strategy conference held by the holding company. Since he would need to eventually get approval from 10-12 people on each account, this personal outreach set the tone for the rest of the pursuit.

John also executed a full digital content marketing strategy to reach these twenty accounts. But, he did it in a very focused way. For example, the blog team helped him write about topics relevant to these 20 accounts, like this one on channel sales. And despite being one of the top agency partners of a marketing automation platform (HubSpot), they resisted the urge to do any sort of templated lead nurturing. Instead, they manually sent highly targeted content to specific leaders at their 20 prospective accounts. They also did some ad re-targeting to reach these people through as many channels as possible.

“We went through all of this to prove that we can be a¬†trusted advisor to them.”

They Provided a Free Digital Assessment to Initiate Their Pitch Process

All of this effort- shaking hands, blogging, ad retargeting etc.- came before sitting down to discuss how they could help. But by then, Kuno had already proven their¬†experience in the exact places where the prospect required help. Now, they needed to demonstrate they could employ the same tactics and have the same results for the prospect’s funnel.

“By completing a free digital assessment, we¬†can provide even more value to the prospect¬†up front. And we can feel confident we will be able to help them improve in specific, measurable ways.”

Kuno does an extensive review of the client’s marketing data within services like Google Analytics, Google AdWords and HubSpot Marketing/CRM. They look at opportunities around all parts of the funnel, but they need to make a quick judgement on which changes should be highest priority.

They communicate their suggestions through 1-click dashboards, like the Pipeline Performance Dashboard shown below. Kuno Creative uses Databox to augment their KPI monitoring and client reporting processes and therefore, has created templates they can quickly use with a new prospect during a pursuit.

“Because we’ve invested heavily in building out our reporting and analytics capabilities, we can create beautiful and consistent looking reports that impress prospects with insights about their sales and marketing funnel inefficiencies.”

The visuals like the one above allow them to easily explain why they recommend specific actions. For example, instead of generically explaining the ways they have improved funnel conversion rates for past clients, they can suggest ways to improve this specific conversion rates for the prospect.

“There are plenty of other agencies that have bulletproof case studies on the exact same topics! We¬†go further by painting the client’s potential future using the¬†prospect’s¬†actual data.”

They Only Create Proposals for Qualified Opportunities

While it may seem like Kuno did a bunch of work before even writing a proposal, it is all work they’ve done before. They’ve been committed to content marketing for years, so the blogging was not much extra effort. They’ve been proactively reaching out to leads for years too, with staff dedicated to it. As mentioned above, they also leveraged their newly-streamlined agency reporting process to efficiency do the audit.

Lastly, they aren’t too eager to do proposals to these clients. While they’ve completed four¬†audits since implementing this new process in the beginning of the year, they’ve only committed to writing one proposal. That doesn’t mean they didn’t talk about next steps with the other four,¬†or that any of them are not moving forward.

“The results of the free assessment set the stage for proposals by identifying areas of weakness and recommendations for improvement. There is no guesswork, and our clients immediately understand the value of our proposed engagements. I expect we’ll close our first deal from this effort in June and the other¬†four may move forward with a paid engagement soon too.”

Just one of these clients could mean hundreds of thousands of dollars of services revenue for Kuno over the lifespan of the engagement. And while they haven’t closed one yet, McTigue reports, “We’re having significantly better conversations with these companies and because of it, we expect to close a high percentage of them this year.”

Ready to Use Data in Your Agency’s Sales Process?

If your agency struggles to differentiate¬†its services, you might want to repeat Kuno’s exercise by evaluating the characteristics of your best clients and pursuing them in a targeted way. ¬†While you may end up putting in more marketing and sales effort to personalize your approach to these target accounts, it will help you differentiate your agency from the pack.

According to our survey data, 30% of agencies insist on access to a prospect’s data before proposing anything. Maybe it’s time you use data more frequently in your sales process?

About the author
Kevin Kononenko Growth Marketer @ Databox. Making it easy for marketers to tell the story of their success. Everton FC supporter. Startup guy.

Get practical strategies that drive consistent growth

Read some
You may also like...
Read more

Account Manager Burnout: How Many Clients Are Too Many?

How many clients are too many before an account manager reaches burnout? We surveyed 48 agencies to find out the ideal number of clients per account manager.

Agencies   |  Apr 6

Read more

Best KPIs for Marketing Agencies

While your client KPIs might be on track, many agencies end up neglecting their own numbers. Here, 29 experts share the KPIs their agency tracks most.

Agencies   |  Jan 25

Read more

23 Marketing Agency Directories Your Agency Shouldn’t Miss in 2023

List your agency in these marketing directories and reach qualified prospects that are serious about hiring an agency.

Agencies   |  Jan 18